The next section describes analysis of competing hypotheses ach, an intuitive, structured method of evaluating evidence for and against a range of hypotheses, designed to avoid three common cognitive biases in decisionmaking. Oct 22, 2015 analysis of competing hypotheses is a simple model for how to think about a complex problem. Analysis of competing hypotheses, ach, is a simple model for how to think about and fuse geospatial information into analytic problems. The next section describes analysis of competing hypotheses. Analysis of competing hypotheses military wiki fandom. Analysis of competing hypotheses an analytical process by former cia analyst richards j heuer, jr.
Fifty intelligence analysts were randomly assigned to use ach or not when completing a hypothesis testing task that had probabilistic ground truth. Pdf applying heuers analysis of competing hypotheses. Draft june 27, 2005 3 broad caveats for the method ach 1. Analysis of competing hypotheses wikimili, the free. Recognizing and countering biases in intelligence analysis.
The intelligence community uses structured analytic techniques to help analysts think critically and avoid cognitive bias. Analysis of competing hypotheses enterprise risk management. Extending heuers analysis of competing hypotheses method. It is an analytic process that identifies a complete set of alternative hypotheses, systematically evaluates data that is consistent and inconsistent with each hypothesis, and rejects hypotheses that contain too much inconsistent data. Analysis of competing hypotheses using subjective logic achsl.
A place for analysis of competing hypotheses ach in cyber. Applying heuers analysis of competing hypotheses ach in the law enforcement intelligence environment. Apr 22, 2009 analysis of competing hypotheses ach is a simple model for how to think about a complex problem when the available information is incomplete or ambiguous, as typically happens in intelligence analysis. Analysis of competing hypotheses using subjective logic dtic. This judgement is used to fill in the gaps in knowledge and is the analysts principal means of managing uncertainty.
Mar 21, 2019 the analysis of competing hypotheses ach. The analysis of competing hypotheses, ach, is a method to aid judgment on important issues requiring careful weighing of alternative explanations or conclusions. Analysis of competing hypotheses ach is a multivariable, qualitative technique that aids judgment on important issues requiring careful weighing of alternative explanations or conclusions. A place for analysis of competing hypotheses ach in. May 12, 2017 one tool the advanced research interns worked with this semester was the analysis of competing hypotheses ach methodology. What i want to share with the digital analytics community is continue reading analysis of competing hypotheses for digital analytics. Data on analysts judgement processes and conclusions were collected using written protocols. It takes you through a process for making a wellreasoned, analytical judgment. Analysis of competing hypotheses, sometimes abbreviated ach, is a tool to aid judgment on important issues requiring careful weighing of alternative explanations or conclusions. As we have included ach in our geospatial analytic method, it takes the geospatial analyst through a process to make wellreasoned, analytical judgments using both nongeospatial and geospatial information. Analysis of competing hypotheses for digital analytics. Hart series 1, no 34 the analysis of competing hypotheses ach in the assessment of chemical warfare activities national defence university department of strategic and defence studies. Intelligence analysis is a complicated task that requires a high degree of analytical judgement under conditions of considerable uncertainty. The analysis of competing hypotheses in intelligence analysis.
In particular, the analysis phase involves the management of hypotheses and the application of prior knowledge. Duplicate title to the analysis of competing hypotheses in intelligence analysis retired, jisc publications router manage acknowledge the intelligence community uses structured analytic techniques to help analysts think critically and avoid cognitive bias. A comparable effort has to be devoted to the science of analysis. Analysis of competing hypotheses ach is a simple model for how to think about a complex problem. It is designed to help analysts avoid confirmation bias in several respects, namely, by explicitly requiring them to a consider alternative hypotheses. Exploring the impact of executive orders using analysis of. This effort has to start with a clear understanding of the inherent strengths and weaknesses of the primary analytic mechanismthe human mindand the way it processes information.
Nov 01, 2016 disprove your hypotheses you can have all the evidence in the world to back one hypothesis but if there is one piece of evidence that disproves it you can reject it. Analysis of competing hypotheses is a simple model for how to think about a complex problem. The major purpose of hypothesis testing is to choose between two competing hypotheses about the value of a population parameter. Analysis of competing hypothesis for investigating lone wolf terrorist. I cited, for example, the paper by valtorta, marco et al. At the time of writing, however, we assessed there to be insufficient evidence to corroborate this claim of attribution to this group, and alternative hypotheses should be considered. Isbn 9789512525751 pdf issn 12364959 the analysis of competing hypotheses ach in the assessment of chemical warfare activities john d. Its simplicity creates both strengths and weaknesses. The analysis of competing hypotheses ach 7 was developed to provide a framework for assisted reasoning that would help overcome these limitations. One tool the advanced research interns worked with this semester was the analysis of competing hypotheses ach methodology.
Assessing the value of structured analytic techniques in the. The analysis of competing hypotheses ach is said to an unbiased methodology for evaluating multiple competing hypotheses for observed data. Analysis has indicated that wannacry samples from february 2017 contained a small section of code identical to those used in previous lazarus campaigns. Building on the work of the analysis of competing hypotheses walkthrough tool, information visualization techniques were used to improve the ach tool. And to be honest i dont work in fashion i work in analytics for a fashion company. Stech, frank j elsaesser, christopher, deception detection by analysis of competing hypotheses pdf, mitre corporation, archived from. A pdf of this type expresses the uncertain probability that a process will. The analysis of competing hypotheses in intelligence. Summary the intelligence community uses structured analytic techniques to help analysts think critically and avoid cognitive bias. How does analysis of competing hypotheses ach pherson. Pdf the analysis of competing hypotheses in intelligence analysis. Ach is designed to ameliorate these problems with intuitive intelligence analysis that arise from human psychology.
Fifty intelligence analysts were randomly assigned to use. The analysis of competing hypotheses using subjective logic achsl 2 was developed to address a range of intelligence analysis issues, including susceptibility to deception, and is an. The intelligence community uses ach methodology when there are multiple potential explanations for adversary behavior or several possible outcomes from actions taken by an ally. The software downloadable here takes an analyst through a process for making a wellreasoned, analytical judgment. Analysis of competing hypotheses ach is an intelligence analysis tool developed by the central intelligence agency to eliminate the cognitive limitations of selecting a hypothesis. Assessing the value of structured analytic techniques in. The open source analysis of competing hypotheses project a free, open source tool for complex research problems.
Disprove your hypotheses you can have all the evidence in the world to back one hypothesis but if there is one piece of evidence that disproves it you can reject it. Our domain lacks discipline in analysis where our hypotheses are not deterministically and immediately testable. In step 3, you worked across the matrix, focusing on a single item of evidence or. May 18, 2017 analysis has indicated that wannacry samples from february 2017 contained a small section of code identical to those used in previous lazarus campaigns. The analysis of competing hypotheses ach is said to an unbiased methodology for. Pdf the analysis of competing hypotheses in intelligence. Analysis of competing hypotheses ach is a simple model for how to think about a complex problem when the available information is incomplete or ambiguous, as typically happens in intelligence analysis. Federal, state and local intelligence organizations, groups, and networks. People often ask me how i went from working for the government to fashion. Software freeware law enforcement intelligence analysis. Analysis of competing hypotheses digital forensics.
The analysis of competing hypotheses in intelligence analysis article pdf available in applied cognitive psychology march 2019 with 382 reads how we measure reads. An analysis of competing hypotheses digital shadows. Resolving goal conflicts via argumentationbased analysis. The analysis of competing hypotheses ach 7 was developed to provide a. The fourth section outlines the major cognitive biases that bedevil analysts. See an alternative views produce a more confident hypothesis one hypothesis will score stronger that the rest h1, h2, h3 based on available evidence. However, we do have hypotheses about what the true values are. Designed for strategic and tactical intelligence analysis national security, defence, trade, etc. Post your analysis to the lesson 7 discussion forum. Singh department of computer science, north carolina state university, raleigh, nc 276958206, usa. Encourages systematic analysis of multiple competing hypotheses.
Resolving goal conflicts via argumentationbased analysis of. Analysis of competing hypotheses using subjective logic. Alternative analysis, and in particular ach, is seen as so important that the cias sherman kent school for intelligence analysis runs a monthly alternative analysis workshop and has introduced an. Pdf in this paper, we evaluate the analysis of competing hypotheses ach method using a normative bayesian probabilistic framework. We examined the use of the analysis of competing hypotheses acha technique designed to reduce confirmation bias. How does analysis of competing hypotheses ach improve intelligence analysis. The challenge is to create better formal methods of analysis that can be used under a wider variety of circumstances and which can handle both empirical data and formallyexpressed beliefs as evidence for. The analysis of competing hypotheses ach provides an unbiased methodology for evaluating multiple competing hypotheses for observed data. Following this, two models of crime analysis are discussed with a view to highlighting commonalities as well as conceptual gaps. Pdf analysis of competing hypothesis for investigating. It helps an analyst overcome, or at least minimize, some of the cognitive limitations that make prescient intelligence analysis so difficult to achieve. Pdf extending heuers analysis of competing hypotheses. Analysis of competing hypotheses using subjective logic simon pope, audun jlsang crc for enterprise distributed systems technology dstc pty ltd level 7, general purpose south the university of queensland, 4072 australia voice. The analysis of competing hypotheses, ach, is a method.
Analysis of competing hypotheses ach the iconic tech. To complete the ach steps of fusion and conclusion. Jul 07, 2008 analysis of competing hypotheses, sometimes abbreviated ach, is a tool to aid judgment on important issues requiring careful weighing of alternative explanations or conclusions. Ach is grounded in basic insights from cognitive psychology, decision analysis, and the scientific method. Extending heuers analysis of competing hypotheses method to. However, little evidence exists of how techniques are applied and whether they are effective. In step 3, you worked across the matrix, focusing on a single item of evidence or argument and examining against each hypotheses. Pdf the intelligence community uses structured analytic techniques to help analysts think critically and avoid cognitive bias. Much of intelligence analysis includes judging the relevance and the value of evidence to determine the likelihood of competing hypotheses. For example, one hypothesis might claim that the wages of men and women are equal, while the alternative might claim that men make more than. It guides the analyst to view intelligence analysis as ceaseless discovery of evidence, hypotheses, and arguments in a nonstationary world, involving collaborative processes of evidence in search of hypotheses, hypotheses in search of evidence, and evidentiary testing of hypotheses 1, 3.
1070 948 1526 680 837 1036 1324 551 1582 540 461 1564 1537 744 1314 1211 1259 1236 808 736 997 982 131 171 181 1210 253 975 1496 1038 949 723 654 1329 1252 856 535 775 1326 454 286 271